Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

US must treat Cuba with respect

Published: Tuesday, March 2, 2010

Updated: Tuesday, March 2, 2010 01:03

A U.S. delegation met with Cuban officials in Havana last week to discuss immigration issues. However, U.S. diplomats raised tensions with their questionable actions during the trip.

Upon arrival, the U.S. delegation, headed by Craig Kelly, deputy assistant secretary of state for Western Hemisphere affairs, was informed of the Cuban government's "opposition to his using his brief stay to organize a provocative event, alien to the spirit of migration talks," according to a statement released by the Cuban Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

The delegation didn't listen and met with political opposition leaders following the official talks.

Elizardo Sanchez, a Cuban dissident and head of the independent Cuban Commission on Human Rights and National Reconciliation, confirmed this, telling The Associated Press that about 40 opposition leaders met with Kelly at the residence of the head of the U.S. Interests Section in Havana.

"We believe in reaching out to broad sectors of society in all countries that we deal with … and we don't make exceptions in particular countries," a senior State Department official said to The AP. He spoke in defense of the delegation on condition of anonymity.

The Cuban authorities are upset — and rightfully so. Working with non-governmental players is a highly provocative act. U.S. officials should only work directly with the Cuban government.

A national security crisis would likely unfold if visiting Cuban diplomats met privately with American dissidents during an official state visit, especially against the U.S. government's wishes

It's even more absurd to suggest that the U.S. is consistent with this approach. When working with European nations, friendly oil-rich Middle East nations or any state with serious international clout, the U.S. would never try this. British or Chinese dissidents are unlikely to find a friendly ear with U.S. diplomats visiting their country.

"Meeting with representatives of civil society who simply want a voice in the future of their country is not subversion," Assistant Secretary of State P.J. Crowley said to CNN.

There are disenfranchised felons in the U.S. with no political voice, and some nations may not agree with the legal reasons for it. That does not mean these nations have the right to work directly with U.S. criminals.

U.S. foreign policy toward Cuba or any nation needs to be built on a conscious effort to respect foreign states' sovereignty, however great the ideological differences. The U.S. has jeopardized its chances of working bilaterally with Cuba.

Cuba allowed medical flights through its airspace and quickly responded to the devastating earthquake in Haiti, reopening two hospitals the day after the quake and sending more than 400 health workers, according to National Public Radio.

"The Ministry of Foreign Affairs reiterates the willingness expressed by the Cuban government to maintain a respectful dialogue about any issue with the United States government, as long as it is between equals, and without detriment to independence, sovereignty or self-determination," the statement from the Cuban government said.

U.S. officials should heed this simple plea and finally show some restraint in dealing with its weaker neighbors.

Justin Rivera is a senior majoring in history.
 

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

5 comments

Justin Rivera
Wed Mar 3 2010 02:22
I think that some Cuban-Americans, who are direct descendants of Cuban nationals who were unhappy with the socialist land redistribution and other programs aimed at the improving the lower classes' state at the upper classes expense in Cuba under Castro, and who left as a result, are unwilling to see past their historical bias.

I challenge you to look at this situation from a neutral party's view, and still try to argue that these actions are not hypocritical on behalf of the U.S. Don't we hold ourselves to a higher standard this?
Or do you think we should travel across the globe and cor-rectify every injustice, because you need the history lesson if so. We shall never move toward a more cosmopolitan and multilateral world while those in the U.S. continue to show no regard or respect for any set of beliefs other than their own.

It is childish to hold such a naive belief that some type of end-goal, where the world is a perfect place and there are no oppressed, is achievable, or that stability and prosperity should be compromised it its pursuit during the meanwhile.

Anonymous
Tue Mar 2 2010 18:05
Because the US doesnt have political prisoners.... Cuba has been nothing but helpful and respectful to the US recently and all we have done is undermine and disrespect them. And past us, our trade partners such as Saudi Arabia and China don't have any humans rights violations, or they at least don't matter bc they are our "friends"
Anonymous
Tue Mar 2 2010 15:13
Cuba is the country with the worst human rights record and is one of the most racially discriminatory in the world, Mr. Zapata Tamayo a black disident that was allowed to die by the represive regime that sentenced him to jail for 34 years for expressing his opinion in favor of human rights and this "history student" who evidently knows little of the history of Cuba and the history of the failed Castro regime which condems it's people to live in squalor with substandard diet which has lead to inumerable dieseases rights this childish column.
Jorge J. Rodriguez
Tue Mar 2 2010 15:04
I do not know what history Mr. Rivera has studied or how far back he has researched during his studies. Mr. Rivera must not know of Fidel Castro's visit to New York when he stayed in a hotel in Harlem instead of the official residence that was prepared for him or of the spectacle he created when he brought live chickens into that hotel. The people with whom Mr. Kelly rightfully met are disidents that are requesting the liberty of expression that Mr. Rivera uses in his letter which are denied to all Cubans for which Mr.Zapata Tamayo gave his life.
Frank E. Hernandez
Tue Mar 2 2010 12:32
How about this... the U.S. will begin to treat the Cuban government with respect once the Cuban government begins to treat its people with respect. It's ridiculous to me for someone to even write something like this, especially right after the death of political prisoner Orlando Zapata Tamayo, who by the way was put in... jail for some BS called "pre-criminal social danger".






log out