Quote approval should never have been commonplace
Earlier this month, The Kenyon Collegian, Kenyon Colleges student newspaper, stopped allowing sources to approve quotes in their articles. This follows similar review rejections made in September by The New York Times and The Harvard Crimson.
The Kenyon Collegian began discussing the issue after witnessing the action taken by other publications, according to a blog post by Collegian Co-Editor-in-Chief Liliana Martinez on collegemediamatters.com.
Though it is good news that many media outlets are finally rejecting this practice of allowing sources to review their quotes before publication, why were so many of them participating in it in the first place? And how many are still doing so?
According to a letter to readers, The Harvard Crimson had been allowing quote approval because key administrators such as the university president, provost and deans would only agree to interviews on this condition. In a world ever regulated, edited and reviewed by public relations representatives, this review process takes power away from journalists.
The function of a journalist is to seek truth and report it or so the Society of Professional Journalists Code of Ethics says. A reporters job is to question a source and receive truthful, candid, accurate quotes on a specific subject. Reporters should be unbiased and portray stories, subjects and sources accurately and sometimes this means portraying them in a negative light. If that is the truth, then that is the truth.
By granting officials control over how their quotes are used, publications are basically handing over control of the entire story. Officials should not say something if they do not want it quoted.
The fact that many officials, both at colleges and universities and in public office, will not agree to interviews without this condition is an unfortunate, tragic example of how difficult it is to get in touch with these public figures. By including a middleman, be it a public relations representative or even physical time to prepare or review information presented, the process becomes complicated and allows for more discrepancy.
The New York Times, one of the most powerful media institutions, should never have been resorting to such a practice, and neither should any other newspaper in the country. As more newspapers come forward rejecting such practice, readers should take a look at what they have been reading. What information has been left out because a source did not want their quote included?
Journalists should make it a goal to provide as much information as possible otherwise, newspapers might as well print press releases and call it a day.
These papers rejection of quote approval should send a strong message to officials being quoted as well
as other publications so that this practice will not be tolerated in the future.
Get Top Stories Delivered Weekly
From Around the Web
More usforacle News Articles
Recent usforacle News Articles
Discuss This Article
MOST POPULAR USFORACLE NEWS
GET TOP STORIES DELIVERED WEEKLY
FOLLOW OUR NEWSPAPER
LATEST USFORACLE NEWS
FROM AROUND THE WEB
- 3 Fishermen Rescued at Sea Thanks to GPS Device
- Mes de la Hispanidad inspira liderazgo, empoderamiento,...
- Majority of Moms and Moms-to-Be Believe in Public...
- Wineries Speak Up About the Benefits of Using Natural Cork
- Taking a Holistic Approach to Fit Living
- Wondering if it's Time to Buy a New Car? Just Check Your...
- Smartphone to Become Wallet -- Are Customers, Businesses...
- Grandparents, Keep Your Meds Up and Away From Young Children
- As Insurers End Coverage for Compounded Drugs, Patients...
- 4 Tips to Start Your Day a Little Earlier
COLLEGE PRESS RELEASES
- Over 2,000 Groups Prepare to “Hit the Streets” with Volunteers and Celebrities for National Voter Registration Day on September 23, 2014
- Peace Corps Director Calls on College Students to Make a Difference After Graduation Through International Service
- USA NETWORK AND VERIZON LAUNCH THE “CHARACTERS UNITE COLLEGE TOUR” COMPETITION FOR STUDENTS TO BRING A USA NETWORK CELEBRITY AND A WORTHY CAUSE TO THEIR CAMPUS
- WHEN GEORGIA SMILED: THE ROBIN MCGRAW REVELATION FOUNDATION TEAMS WITH PIVOT AND STUDENTS OF THE WORLD TO LAUNCH THE #iASPIRE GRANT CONTEST
- Latino Groups Launch National Campaign to Deliver Record Latino Turnout for 2014 Midterm Elections