Computer essay graders put students at disadvantage
Students anxiously awaiting results on papers during finals week may be wishing professors could grade them faster, yet a new technological development may provide the perfect example of be careful what you wish for.
Computer essay graders are now more efficient, accurate and cost-effective than humans, setting U.S. education down a dangerous course.
A recent study by the University of Akron concluded that computer-generated essay scores are just as, or in some cases, more reliable and much faster than human graders.
E-Rater, an automated reader created by the Educational Testing Service (ETS), can grade 16,000 essays in 20 seconds, according to the New York Times. Pearson Education Inc. says human readers working at maximum capacity can score 30 essays in an hour.
The robot-graders save time, and therefore save teachers and standardized testing companies money, but they cant verify facts or fully comprehend the meaning behind the words they scan for structural and technical difficulties.
Massachusetts Institute of Technology professor Les Perelman found that the e-Rater does not consider content, but rather length, sentence structure and word usage. An e-Rater cant tell if information is factual and doesnt care if you say the War of 1812 started in 1945, he told the Times.
With Florida teachers salaries tied to their students test scores, thanks to a bill signed by Gov. Rick Scott in 2011, those desperate for a pay raise can easily coach students to outsmart the system instead of worrying about actual content, reducing the value of a students education.
University students may also rightly be concerned at the idea of a test essay dictating their college prospects and, thus, their futures, only getting 1/800 of a second of thought.
If e-Raters were used in grading college papers, even larger questions would be raised about a college educations worth as the cost of tuition increases every year.
According to the Times, the e-Rater has already been used to grade essays for the Graduate Record Exam (GRE). While e-Rater creators said GRE samples are also read by humans, the website for the Graduate Management Admission Test, gmat-pacer.com, states that human graders are aware that there is a computer double-checking their work, and they are more likely to follow the e-Raters strict grading parameters.
The site urges students to be particularly concerned with structure, use buzzwords and be a conformist the e-Rater is not programmed to appreciate individuality, humor or poetic inspiration.
Though such programs can help identify technical issues in students writing, they can in no way replace the careful thought and logic that can only come from an intelligent human being. Individual thought is a gift that educators shouldnt discard so quickly.
Get Top Stories Delivered Weekly
More usforacle News Articles
Recent usforacle News Articles
Discuss This Article
MOST POPULAR USFORACLE
GET TOP STORIES DELIVERED WEEKLY
FOLLOW OUR NEWSPAPER
LATEST USFORACLE NEWS
- AAC Player of the Year removed from USF softball
- Ethics committee opens investigation of SG president
- Student bands get chance for the big stage
- First all-ticket presidential debate brings calls for change
- The threat of empty promises
- Bulls enter critical final stretch
- Tampa design firm urges city to play
FROM AROUND THE WEB
- Protecting Seniors Online from Scams, Hacks and Tax Fraud
- Rehydrating for Optimal Health
- Five Reasons You Need Cell Phone Insurance Now
- The One Super Bowl Fact You Still May Not Know
- Companies Are Discovering That Pittsburgh Is Good for...
- Millennials Go House Hunting, and Here's What They Crave
- Estate Plans: You're Not Doing Anyone a Favor by Avoiding...
- What Would You Have to Give Up to Pay for An Unexpected...
- Four Tips to Keep Your Kids' Teeth Healthy And Clean
- Local Community Newspapers Go Digital
COLLEGE PRESS RELEASES
- N. American Effie Awards Announces 2017 Collegiate Effie Competition
- Students Increasingly Turn To GoFundMe To Pay For College
- O2 BARS: LATEST RAGE AT COLLEGE DE-STRESS, SOCIAL, & WELLNESS EVENTS
- Deadline Approaching for Phi Kappa Phi Study Abroad Grants
- ESA Foundation launches 2017-18 Scholarship Program